Colin Farrell

Peter Lake

Jessica Brown Findlay

Beverly Penn

Russell Crowe

Pearly Soames

William Hurt

Isaac Penn

Jennifer Connelly

Virginia Gamely

Will Smith

Judge

Eva Marie Saint

Willa (Adult)

Graham Greene

Humpstone John

Matt Bomer

Young Man

Kevin Durand

Cesar Tan

Kevin Corrigan

Romeo Tan

Lucy Griffiths

Mrs. Lake

Finn Wittrock

Gabriel

Neka Zang

Ballroom Dancer

Michael Crane

Ellis Isle Doctor

Brian Hutchison

Ellis Isle Official

Alan Doyle

Dingy Worthington

Jon Patrick Walker

Optometrist

Maurice Jones

Cecil Mature

Mckayla Twiggs

Young Willa

Matthew R. Staley

Oyster Boy

Scott Grimes

Carriage Driver

Brenda Wehle

Governess

Tom Morrissey

Butler